Now Reading
The portrait as witness and management

The portrait as witness and management

The portrait as witness and control

From: Vaught’s ‘Sensible Character Reader’

Drawing can lead us into many unusual territories, one in every of which is ‘witness description composite drawing’. In the US artists are employed by police departments, normally within the forensic proof division.  As an example witness description composite drawing is what the artist Harvey Pratt has spent many of the final 50 years engaged on. He has labored as a forensic artist for varied police forces, while additionally being recognised as an achieved grasp Native American Indian artist. In reality it was this twin function that first attracted me to his work.

The time period ‘composite artwork’ was initially used when facial options (eyes, noses, lips, hair, facial shapes) have been compiled to finish a complete composite of a face. This process was for use by a witness who was guided by means of a strategy of the right way to match these varied facial options with a purpose to type a picture of a suspect. Witness description composite drawings have been principally the identical method however have been drawn free hand and based mostly on an interview of a witness or sufferer to find out what somebody would possibly appear like. These drawings are thought to be investigative aids and they’re used to assist slender down suspect lists. Witness description drawing can be utilized not solely to determine suspects but additionally determine tattoos, automobiles and different gadgets {that a} witness would possibly describe throughout an interview. 

Beneath are examples of witness description composite drawings made by Harvey Pratt beside photographs of the topic later recognized. 

Thought of one of many main forensic artists in the US, Harvey Pratt spent over 50 years in regulation enforcement, finishing 1000’s of witness description drawings and a whole bunch of sentimental tissue reconstructions. You might say that Harvey Pratt had an attention-grabbing portfolio, being a Cheyenne and Arapaho tribal member and in addition being recognised as an achieved grasp Native American Indian artist. Each these features of his working life as an artist concerned making portraits of individuals, some being one step eliminated each emotionally and by way of expertise and others made to rejoice his ethnic origins and feeling of belonging to a tribal tradition. 

Harvey Pratt: Drawing of a Native American 

I am positive a few of you can be anxious by the truth that somebody like Harvey needs to be launched beneath the umbrella of a fantastic artwork drawing weblog, however one of many points I’m attempting to open out is the place are the boundaries between fantastic artwork, illustration and different occupations whereby comparable abilities are used? All of those individuals are known as artists and the artwork world is liable to snobbery, so it’s all the time worthwhile stepping again to discover how broad the church of the artist actually is, and as we achieve this maybe we additionally should ask questions as to how does an artist contribute to society? 

A really comparable career to witness description drawing is after all courtroom drawing. Within the UK pictures should not allowed to be taken while a trial is in progress. A courtroom sketch is outlined as an ‘inventive depiction’ of the proceedings in a court docket of regulation and naturally because of this information media should depend on sketch artists for illustrations of the proceedings, which might be the principle means that most of the people get to see hand drawn portraits of individuals. 

Priscilla Coleman: Naomi Campbell and Piers Morgan for ITN

Within the UK, a courtroom illustrator is an extremely area of interest commerce, and a dying one. For the time being listed below are 4 skilled courtroom sketch artists: Priscilla Coleman, Siân Frances, Julia Quenzler and Elizabeth Prepare dinner. Nonetheless new legal guidelines have been handed in January 2020 permitting cameras into the nation’s Crown Courts, together with the Outdated Bailey, to broadcast the sentencing remarks on high-profile felony circumstances, which implies that court docket artists are solely wanted for the much less ‘attention-grabbing’ features of a court docket case. Drawing in court docket, or making a picture of any form, be {that a} {photograph}, doodle or in any other case, is prohibited in British courts. So courtroom artists not solely should be expert portraitists however additionally they should have wonderful recollections for faces and locations. To make their photos, they take written notes in the course of the case, earlier than transferring exterior to the press room to attract their photos as quick as potential, each to make sure accuracy and to allow their purchasers, (newspapers and broadcast media) to get photos in time for varied deadlines. 

Priscilla Coleman: Artist’s notes from courtroom observations

I like to consider the notes taken by these artists as drawings in their very own proper. They’re a part of the method of remembrance and are used as triggers to make sure photos are introduced again as precisely as potential. 

The courtroom artist is a talented compiler of facial photos and they’re making notes realizing they’re going to assemble a picture of a face inside a couple of minutes of creating their notes. They perceive how heads are constructed and have coaching and years of expertise. Examine this to a criminal offense witness’s reminiscence of an individual that’s recalled maybe a number of days later or much more, that then must be translated or communicated to an artist who then has to render the picture. Once I checked out communication idea I identified that Shannon and Weaver wished to guarantee that communication techniques labored properly. The mannequin they got here up with permits us to simply see the place issues in a communication system may go flawed. 

Specifically the knowledge supply must be working in such a means that it’s decipherable by the knowledge vacation spot. So on this case now we have somebody who was in all probability very pressured on the time of the expertise, having to recall the facial options of somebody they might solely have glanced at for a number of seconds. Not solely that, they’ll have had no coaching within the recognition and identification of facial options and no specialist language to assist them both.  You must do this your self, give a verbal description of somebody to a different pupil and ask them to make a portrait from that description. The receiver additionally must be adequate to grasp or not distort the message coming by means of. On this case both the police artist makes use of their expertise based mostly on earlier encounters or they use the composite mannequin. The abilities of the drawer and the means of the drawer to place this data into an efficient form for transmission are once more very important.  You in a short time start to understand how superb it’s that any communication is made in any respect. However, and that is the true problematic concern, what each individuals on this communication system have in widespread is a set of preconceptions, stereotypes and concepts about what individuals appear like and that is maybe what they’re actually speaking. If we have a look at Vaught’s Sensible Character Reader’s trustworthy face, as seen on the high of this put up, we see maybe one finish of a stereotype scale that the crime sufferer and police artist are measuring their concepts in opposition to. As an example in lots of experiments in relation to feelings instigated by facial kind, individuals reply that they belief and discover honesty in faces which might be extra symmetrical. Symmetry is on the core of a police artist’s working system. Beneath is a verbatim account given by a working police artist of how they got down to do their work, the dominated pad is what they use as a place to begin for each drawing. 

A police artist’s dominated drawing pad

“I begin the drawing by having the witness undergo the FBI’s Facial Identification Catalog characteristic by characteristic. I all the time begin by having the witness look by means of the FIC for the shapes of the suspect’s head, or face. This is essential as a result of the form of the pinnacle is without doubt one of the three most important elements to getting near the suspect’s precise look. I stress it’s significance. I set my drawing up on my paper earlier than each composite. That is additionally essential as a result of it retains all of the drawings to a sure scale and helps with symmetry”.


“I then transfer on to the suspect’s eyes. I rush the witness just a bit bit so that they don’t make themselves loopy all of the completely different eyes. I clarify the significance of selecting solely the closest set of eyes. I let the witness know options might be modified, or fine-tuned, when the road drawing is accomplished. I make sure that the witness understands they need to focus however not get pissed off by all the alternatives”.


“As soon as they select a set of eyes, I sketch within the eyes and eye brows of the eyes they selected. I don’t wish to nit-pick them on options. Eyebrows don’t usually make or break a likeness so, in the event that they bear in mind specifics I’ll notice it, if not I skip the eyebrow part”.

“I take advantage of an everyday 2B pencil as a result of it’s tougher than my ending pencil, erases simpler, and attracts lighter. I’ve the witness begin noses whereas I sketch the eyes. I draw the nostril whereas I’ve the witness on the lookout for a mouth”.

“I draw the mouth whereas the witness seems by means of the chins. I draw the chin and sides of the face, after referring again to the form of the face. I all the time draw the highest of the pinnacle with simply the brow. I all the time put generic ears on, except they have been a characteristic the witness remembered particularly”.

“I get the witness to search out the coiffure someplace within the e book. As soon as the road drawing is accomplished I’ve the witness look it over. I make adjustments by erasing with the kneadable eraser and re-sketching till the drawing is as near the suspect because the witness can bear in mind. I’ve the witness charge the road drawing on a scale of 1 to 10, “ten” being a portrait (actually shut), and “one” being no the place close to shut. Now, with the road drawing as near the suspect because the witness can bear in mind, I add pores and skin tone and shading”. 

“I take advantage of a 9b woodless pencil as a result of it’s smooth, goes on darkish, and smudges simply. I get good distinction between lights and darks. Shading takes observe. Reaching a great pores and skin tone is essential as a result of it should make the composite plausible. After, the composite has pores and skin tone it ought to seem nearer within the ranking scale, or at the very least no change”. 

Within the instance above it’s attention-grabbing to see how the artist leads the crime sufferer by means of a collection of choice making decisions, ones that should affect the ultimate consequence. 

What the artist is doing could be very intently modelled on the ‘Photograph-fit’ package. 

The Photograph-fit’ package

The Photograph-FIT package for police forces was derived from the work of Jacques Penry. Within the video clip beneath you possibly can see him at work. The video is a well timed reminder of how social conference was typically considered being truth and that outdated beliefs in physiognomy, or the observe of assessing an individual’s character or persona from their outer look endured for a few years after they have been proven to be false.

Jacques Penry describes his system

Physiognomy as a ‘science’ was developed Johann Caspar Lavater (1741-1801), his 4 volumes of ‘Physiognomic Fragments’ have been common all through Western Europe, and so they started to affect how individuals actually pictured themselves. In Central Europe, there was an obsession with silhouette footage, normally created by slicing an individual’s profile out of black cardboard. Lavater advocated the usage of this method as a result of it made face profiles simply measurable.

Lavater’s equipment for making silhouettes 

The ‘proof’ that you simply have been an upstanding citizen may then after your portrait had been made, be framed and put in your wall. 

Portrait by Robert Pal

Sure artists, equivalent to Robert Pal, developed the silhouette portrait as a specialism and simply as all the opposite parts within the photos he made are indicators of sophistication and standing, the profile itself would have been barely adjusted to make sure that the individual depicted had the correct form of facial form. 

Our continued want to regulate how we glance in relation to how facial options are learn inside society implies that as an example, as a result of selfies distort the face many individuals are present process cosmetic surgery on their noses with a purpose to make them smaller. Cell phone pictures misrepresent seems, as a result of from the space of an arms size, most lenses will make the nostril seem larger in proportion to the remainder of the face. People who find themselves not photographers do not realise that digital camera lenses should not the identical as regular eyesight. Nonetheless the selfie turns into the ‘actuality’ and is measured by social conference and that’s itself decided by very outdated concepts which might be nonetheless rooted in ideas that got here from physiognomy. 

There’s something bizarre about all these depictions of individuals. They’re both abject within the sense that measured ‘individuals’ are fully with out delight or dignity; or they’re about lack of self price. Julia Kristeva in ‘the Powers of Horror’ states that the abject refers to the human response to a threatened breakdown in that means brought on by the lack of the excellence between topic and object or between self and different. These photos of faces appear to embody all of those definitions and but on the identical time they attain out right into a western European previous that exhibits a seamless have to measure and decide ourselves by means of measurement. In line with Foucault, information is simply potential inside an unlimited system of energy relationships that enable that information to come back to be. I.e. society permits these unusual readings to proceed and be used as if they’re ‘information’ as a result of some highly effective individuals discover it helpful. 

In 1902 Vaught’s ‘Sensible Character Reader’ was revealed. It is arduous to imagine that this can be a Twentieth Century publication, because it appears virtually Medieval in its reasoning. 

It’s attention-grabbing to match and distinction the whole humbug of Vaught’s ‘Sensible Character Reader’ above with the pictures beneath as set out by a up to date firm promoting its abilities in cosmetic surgery. 

These photos are supposed to reveal how rhinoplasty can enhance your facial concord

It isn’t a far take away from stating that broad headed people and animals are vicious or individuals with convex curves to their noses are deceitful, to stating {that a} broad nostril or one with a convex curve is un-harmonious. As we are going to see after we come to the most important anthropometric factors for facial harmonisation, the faces that ‘scientists’ use to take the measurements from, match a really slender stereotype, and by extension after we start to have a look at fairness in facial recognition applied sciences, we discover that these applied sciences have been as soon as once more invented by individuals who see white faces because the norm and the additional away from that norm we get the much less correct is the know-how. Irrespective of how far measurement is taken with a purpose to develop objectivity, it will appear to be apparent that we cant escape bias and subjectivity in our studying of faces. If that’s the case it’s in all probability significantly better simply to just accept that and spend extra time exposing ourselves to different individuals’s concepts of magnificence and character, in order that at the very least we come to understand that what we predict is simply a perspective and that that outdated cliche ‘magnificence is within the eye of the beholder’ has extra going for it than we are inclined to suppose. 

Measurement and faces is an extended working concern. Durer’s ‘4 Books of Human Proportions’ (‘Vier Bücher von Menschlicher Proportionen), is one other try to got down to give mathematical precision to the visualisation of faces. 


Durer, just like the forensic police artist, was trying to develop a system that would seize the just about indefinable essence of what it’s to be a person. 

Our present obsession with faces and the selfie, as already urged, leads us into cosmetic surgery, an space the place facial measurement is an obsession, such an obsession that it has led to a selected self-discipline, ‘faciometrics’. Faciometrics consists of creating direct measurements from predefined anthropometric factors. In an effort to do that a facial ruler is used and measurements linked to standardised references for quantitative evaluation. The connection between these measurements then guides facial interpretation. A Sensible Information for Orofacial Harmonisation, states that ‘with these normative parameters, we will information harmonisation procedures and get better facial proportions, making facial options extra much like the reference.’ ‘On this means, we are going to obtain extra individualised planning that will likely be a extra assertive strategy within the proposed remedy.’  See:

Magnificence Setup ruler (A) Caliper (B)

The desk beneath units out the principle anthropometric factors for facial harmonisation.






Some extent at on the hairline within the midline of the brow


Most distinguished midpoint between eyebrows



Internal commissure of palpebral fissure (left and proper)




Outer commissure of palpebral fissure (left and proper)



The black circle within the middle of the iris.


The midline level of the nasal root and nasofrontal area.



Most distinguished midpoint of nasal tip

Nasal Alare



Most lateral level of alar contour (left and proper)




The purpose of essentially the most lateral smooth tissue overlying the zygomatic arch (left and proper).


See Also
A few thoughts about artist's research


Midpoint of columellar base at junction of higher lip

The purpose on the midline of better concavity within the facial contour of the higher lip, between the subnasale level and the higher lip.




The purpose at every elevated margin of the philtrum simply above the vermilion line

Labiale superius


The midpoint of the vermilion line of the higher lip



Midpoint of the labial fissure between gently closed lips



Lateral extent of labial commissure (left and proper)



The midpoint of the decrease vermilion line




Probably the most lateral level on the mandibular angle (gonial angle). Its location is near that of the bony gonion. (left and proper)


The purpose on the midline with better concavity on the facial contour of the decrease lip, positioned between the decrease lip and the smooth chin. It’s the deepest level of the mentolabial fold.



Probably the most anterior midpoint of the chin.



The bottom level on the midline of the smooth tissue of the chin. That is the bottom level within the measurement of facial top.

Inside a number of moments now we have moved from the abject to a set of issues which might be all about magnificence. Durer was on the lookout for harmonic proportion, and so is the plastic surgeon. The drawings completed by the police forensic artists are an try to achieve management of what’s unknown, an try to search out the felony face, a mission I’d have thought doomed by subjectivity. However so are the requirements of magnificence we see set out within the supporting data for these coping with faciometrics. These photos, normally of white girls, are one more problematic idea. The unconscious bias in our actions and beliefs, just isn’t in reality unconscious, its fairly straightforward to see that the fashions these facial options are based mostly on are of a sure kind and the sort displays the dominant traits of the individuals who management the know-how. 

Drawing as each witness and management exhibits us that what we might usually see as actions exterior of fantastic artwork drawing as a self-discipline, are in reality areas that spotlight points for any artist doing one thing as apparently easy as making a picture of somebody’s face. As quickly as I start to attract I am reminded of these hours of observe as a pupil, all the time being instructed to measure the scenario once more, all the time been pushed in direction of an concept of accuracy. Surprisingly the extra you have been capable of grasp issues like perspective and get what you have been drawing ‘proper’ the extra you have been requested to now push previous superficial ‘likeness’ and to now search for the motion of notion, the traces of head motion that you simply initially had tried to iron out however which now turned very important to the ‘life’ of the trying and its seize within the drawing. 

Drawing of a face utilizing eye monitoring know-how

What we are literally doing after we have a look at a face is a number of issues directly. Initially checking struggle or flight impulses, which will likely be completed virtually earlier than you possibly can start to consider what you’re doing, after which testing a complete host of different bits of incoming data, standing and sophistication, usefulness, sexual curiosity, kinship, curiosity in me, similarity and distinction, and so forth. and so forth. and as we do that we scan, attempting to select up adjustments in eye form, frowning, smile strains and so forth and so forth in order that we will set up a correct relationship with this encountered different, one we will construct upon even additional after we each open our mouths. However have a look at how completely different the static measured drawings are to the drawings measured by eye monitoring know-how. It’s now a lot tougher to inform what kind of individual we’re as a result of we’re involved with motion and a collection of occasions and never an remoted second. 

I’ve just lately been exploring portraiture myself, an space of artwork observe that is stuffed with clichés and a perceived want for ‘likenesses’ and one which on the entire I’ve all the time urged college students steer properly away from, however individuals persist in making them, so quite than keep away from the issue, I’ve determined to  deal with it head on. The primary concern after all being ‘likeness’. Likeness almost all the time comes up when in dialog with somebody from exterior of the artwork enterprise. “It seems similar to {a photograph}” being many individuals’s judgement name in the case of likeness and naturally the easiest way for a picture to be “similar to {a photograph}” is to work from one. This personally appears a redundant train so I by no means use pictures. Likeness can also be measured in opposition to a usually seen static picture, so I by no means ask my sitters to maintain nonetheless, I simply reply to the interplay of an exchanged dialog and as supplies come into play I let the supplies work together with myself and what I’m experiencing. The photographs due to this fact develop into data of time spent with somebody, quite than depictions of them. This feels far more trustworthy and about individuals or encounters quite than renderings and copies. I wish to keep away from methods of working that are inclined to get individuals themselves as if seen in a mirror, and checking for likeness. I need individuals to start trying on the photos as in the event that they have been new issues, new figures shaped from paint and ink and pens and brushes, issues that speak their very own language and which you need to have a look at very rigorously if you wish to hearken to what they’re saying. 

From an ongoing collection of encounters with individuals

What's Your Reaction?
In Love
Not Sure
View Comments (0)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll To Top